ART. I. A History of England from the First Invasion by the Ro- mans. By John Lingard, D.D. 8vo. Vols. XI., XII., II. Journal of a Nobleman; comprising an Account of his Travels, and a Narrative of his Residence at Vienna during III. Thoughts on Man, his Nature, Productions, and Discove- IV. A Year in Spain. By a Young American. V. 1. Summer and Winter Hours. By Henry Glassford Bell. 2. The Assassins of the Paradise, an Oriental Tale, in four Cantos. By the Author of Abassah. 3. The Siege of Constantinople, in three Cantos, with other 4. The Ascent of Elijah; a Seatonian Poem. By the Rev. R. Parkinson, M.A., of St. John's, Cambridge. VIII. A Sermon on 1 Corinthians, xi. 12, preached before the University of Oxford, at St. Mary's, on Sunday, Febru- ary 6, 1831. By the Rev. H. B. Bulteel, M. A., late 6. The Bereaved; Kenilworth, and other Poems. By the 7. The Moorish Queen; a Record of Pompeii, and other VI. A Selection from the Papers of the Earls of Marchmont, in the possession of the Right Honorable Sir George Henry Rose, illustrative of Events from 1685 to 1750. 563 VII. A Narrative of a Visit to the Court of Sinde; a Sketch of IX. A Practical Treatise on Rail-roads, and Interior Commu- nication in general, containing an Account of the Per- formances of the different Locomotive Engines at and subsequent to the Liverpool Contest; upwards of two hundred and sixty Experiments, with Tables of the com- parative Value of Canals and Rail Roads, and the Power of the present Locomotive Engines. Illustrated by numerous Engravings. By Nicholas Wood, Colliery Viewer, Member of the Institution of Civil Engineers, &c. 592 X. Narrative of a Voyage to the Pacific and Behring's Straits, to co-operate with the Polar Expedition, performed in his Majesty's ship Blossom, under the command of Capt. F. W. Beechey, R. N., F. R. S., &c. in the years 1825, 26, 27, 28. Published by authority of the Lords ib. XII. An Outline of Sematology: or an Essay towards establish- XIII. The Family Classical Library, or English Translations of the most valuable Greek and Latin Classics, with highly finished Engravings of the Authors. XIV. 1. Plain Advice to Landlords and Tenants, Lodging-house 2. A Familiar Survey of the Laws respecting Masters and XV. The Life of John Walker, M.D. By John Epps, M.D., &c. ib. XVI. Guy's Geographia Antiqua; or School Treatise on Ancient Geography, upon a new plan. By Joseph Guy, junior. 618 XVII. The Extraordinary Black Book, comprising an Exposition of the United Chnrch, &c. &c., Civil List, &c. XVIII. The Life and Writings of Henry Fuseli, Esq., M.A.R.A. an Instantaneous Communication with the Shore in Ship- wreck, and illuminating the Scene in the dark and tem- pestuous Night. By John Murray, F.S.A. XX. An Examination of the Doctrines of Value, as set forth by Adam Smith, Ricardo, M'Culloch, &c. By C. F. Cotterill 620 XXI. Invention of an effective and unfailing Method for forming - ib. XXII. An Historical Account of the Island of St. Vincent XXIII. The Medical Annual for 1831. By R. Reece, M.D. XXIV. The Pious Minstrel, a Collection of Sacred Poetry. XXV. Sketches of Venetian History XXVI. Narrative of Discovery and Adventure in the Polar Regions ib. THE MONTHLY REVIEW. JANUARY, 1831. ART. I.—1. Annales de l'Association de la Propagation de la Foi, Recueil Périodique des Lettres des Evêques et des Missionaires des Missions des deux Mondes, et de tous les documens relatifs aux Missions et à l'Association de la Propagation de la Foi. 8vo. pp. 540. Louvain : chez Vanlinthout et Vandenzande. 1829. 2. Recueil des Lettres des Evêques et des Missionaires des Missions des deux Mondes, publié par l'Association de la Propagation de la Foi, faisant suite à toutes les Editions des Lettres edifiantes. 8vo. pp. 528. Louvain: chez Vanlinthout et Vandenzande. 1825. THE Conversion to christianity of those communities of mankindunhappily too numerous-which are still immersed in the darkness of idolatry and paganism, must be an object of the greatest importance to every individual, whatever may be his country or his creed, who has the sense to perceive, and a heart to feel for, the greatest of all wants to which his fellow creature can be exposedthe want of that knowledge whereby his eternal welfare may be secured. Societies have been established for this great purpose upon the continent time out of mind. The conversion of infidels forms a leading, though, we believe, not the principal part of the duties of the college long since founded at Rome, under the title "de propaganda fide." A powerful and active association exists also in Paris, having branches in most of the departments of France, under a similar appellation, whose exclusive object is to extend the Christian religion, and to assist, by every means in its power, numbers of missionaries who are dispersed in various regions of the two hemispheres, for the purpose of carrying thither the light of the gospel. Minor confraternities of a similar description are found in Portugal and Spain, the two Sicilies and Austria. The pious desire expressed by George III., that every one of his subjects should be possessed of a Bible, and able to read it, gave VOL. XVI. NO. LXV. B rise, directly or indirectly, to the many associations which now flourish amongst us, constituted originally for the noble end which that revered sovereign was so anxious to see accomplished, but long since enlarged upon a more comprehensive scale, embracing, it may be said, the whole of the inhabited world in their views. The institution of missions which would be the means of circulating the scriptures in different tongues, throughout all nations, the neighbouring as well as the distant, became an essential portion of their magnificent scheme. These Biblical and Missionary Associations have been now in operation, we believe, for more than twenty years. They have collected and expended princely revenues. They have agents in all parts of the globe; the remotest islands of the South, Pacific, and Indian Seas, have been visited by their officers. We have heard it more than once proclaimed that idolatry was annihilated, not merely in the small islands,-but that Tartary, Persia, and India itself, were about to acknowledge the triumphs of British exertion, and to adopt the religion of the cross. It is not our purpose to draw any detailed comparison between the labours of the French and those of the English Associations. We may, however, we hope, without offending persons of any religion, glance slightly at what the former have done, as well as the means by which they have done it; and afterwards shew what the latter have accomplished, or rather what they have not accomplished; and point out the signal failures which they have sustained, especially in India, to which their cares have been long and earnestly directed. It becomes necessary to speak out and firmly upon this subject, which has hitherto been treated in a manner calculated only to deceive the public mind, and to keep up the influx of money, which, from year to year, is expended not merely in an unprofitable, but an absolutely mischievous course of Biblical and Missionary operations. If our views of the results of their measures be incorrect, we may be contradicted, and our arguments may be refuted. But if we be right, it will be for the leaders of those associations to repair, if they can, the errors into which they have fallen, or to abandon the delusive projects which they have in hand, -projects which seem calculated only to benefit the individuals who live by them, to impose in the grossest manner upon the benevolence of this country, and to perpetuate the ignorance of the Pagan world. We believe that most of the travellers who have visited the less frequented parts of North and South America, agree in acknowledging the attachment which subsists between the French, Spanish, and Portuguese Missionaries, and the native Indians to whom they conveyed the truths of christianity. Even Robertson could devote time to the examination, and eloquence to the praise, of the labours of the Jesuits in Paraguay. Upon the banks of the Maranon, and in some of the wildest districts of Spanish America, the names of the missionaries who planted the cross amongst them are still sacred in tradition. Where the succession has been uninterruptedly preserved, the missionaries are looked up to as Patriarchs, and beloved as the fathers of the people, over whose welfare they are appointed to watch. The sphere of the French missionaries in the new world has been confined chiefly to the northern provinces. They have every where experienced the most cordial reception among what we call the savage tribes the Osages, the Ottawas, the Delawares, the Kansas, the Sioux, and many others whose very names have been but lately made known to us. In the reports which the missionaries have given of their proceedings, they occasionally mingle traits and anecdotes of these tribes, which are worth a passing notice. In addressing the Indians, it is necessary to use allegory profusely, but at the same time with the utmost propriety of application. Their speeches are abrupt, and composed of a few sentences. They are remarkably close and subtile reasoners, and in arguing with them, he who has any hope of convincing them, must take care to be strictly consecutive and logical, for if he wander in any degree from his subject, they will mistrust him, thinking that his purpose is not to instruct, but to deceive. They have usually their chosen spokesman, and are never embarrassed for an answer, which is given with an acuteness that sometimes surprises a stranger. Indeed, when perfectly sober, they have little of the savage about them beyond the name and the costume. When a traveller is under the necessity of stopping at their encampments, he is treated with the utmost hospitality. There are few of the Indian tribes who have not some idea, often certainly rather gross, of one only God, who is sovereign master of the whole universe. They call him the "Disposer of Life," or the "Great Spirit." It is said, upon good information, that several of these communities, although they have never yet seen a white man, pay the homage of their adoration to one God, to whom they offer every morning the first mouthful of smoke which they draw from their pipes, and the first morsel of their food. There are, however, some races who adore what they call the "beautiful star," to which they occasionally, it would seem, sacrifice human victims, who are fattened some time previously for the purpose. An instance is given in the Recueil des Lettres of the belief which some of the Indians entertain, as to the existence of a God. Near St. Louis, in Kentucky, one day, a savage, taking by the hand the superior of the missionary seminary established there, addressed him in these terms : "I know," said the Indian, " that you and your companions are the Ministers of the Great Spirit: that you hold in your hands the papers which contain his mandates, and that you are charged to point out to others by your words and your example, the path which they should pursue, if they hope to reach the presence of the Great Spirit. As for me, I know only that He exists. When I lie down to rest, 1 raise my hands |