 | 1875 - 500 sidor
...memorandum of the " terms, yet they were not to sign it as an agreement until " Abernethie was consulted. I grant the risk that such a " defence may be set...suspicion : but, if it be proved that in fact the paper K was signed with the express intention that it_should not " be an agreement, the other party cannot... | |
 | New York (State). Superior Court (New York), James Clark Spencer, Samuel Jones - 1879 - 652 sidor
...juries will look upon defenses of this kind with suspicion unless there be good grounds to sustain them, but if it be proved that in fact the paper was signed with the express intention that it should not be a contract unless something else be done, the other party cannot fix it as a contract upon those so... | |
 | Sir William Reynell Anson - 1880 - 442 sidor
...not to sign it as an agreement until Abernethie was consulted. I grant the risk that such a defense may be set up without ground; and I agree that a jury should therefore always look on such a defense with suspicion; but, it it be proved that in fact the paper was signed with the express intention... | |
 | Sir William Reynell Anson - 1880 - 494 sidor
...as an agreement until Abernethie was consulted. I grant the risk that such a defense may be set np without ground; and I agree that a jury should therefore always look on such a defense with suspicion; but, if it be proved that in fact the paper was signed with the express intention... | |
 | 1889 - 878 sidor
...parol. Said ERLE, J., in Рут v. Campbell (1856), 6 E. & B. 370, in sustaining such a defense, " I grant the risk that such a defence may be set up...that a jury should therefore always look on such a defense with suspicion." And in all the cases where such a defense has been sustained, so far as we... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court, John Chandler Bancroft Davis, Henry Putzel, Henry C. Lind, Frank D. Wagner - 1894 - 758 sidor
...the terms contained in it were conclusive, and could not be varied by parol evidence, yet, if it were proved that in fact the paper was signed with the...that it should not be an agreement, the other party could not fix it as an agreement upon those so signing. " The distinction in point of law," he said,... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1894 - 756 sidor
...the terms contained in it were conclusive, and could not be varied by parol evidence, yet, if it were proved that in fact the paper was signed with the...that it should not be an agreement, the other party could not fix it as an agreement upon those so signing. "The distinction in point of law," he said,... | |
 | Charles Burke Elliott - 1898 - 342 sidor
...Pym v. Campbell, 6 El. & Bl. 370, in sustaining such a defense, "I grant the risk that such a defense may be set up without ground, and I agree that a jury should therefore look on such a defense with suspicion." And in all the cases where such a defense has been sustained,... | |
 | Jeremiah Smith - 1902 - 768 sidor
...varied by parol. Said Erie, J., in Pym v. Campbell, 6 El. & Bl. 370, in sustaining such a defence : " I grant the risk that such a defence may be set up...without ground, and I agree that a jury should therefore look on such a defence with suspicion." And in all the cases where such a defence has been sustained,... | |
| |
I grant the risk that such a defence may be set up without ground; and I agree that a jury should therefore always look on such a defence with suspicion: but if it be proved that in fact the paper was signed with the express intention that it should not... 
