geological discoverer, early despaired of forcing science on the University, and would take no steps to promote it until the British Association, meeting at Oxford in 1847, proclaimed in tones which left a sting behind the scandal of its miserable equipment and its inefficient teaching. From this time the advocates of reform threw a new spirit into their efforts : their numbers, largely increased, were led by a champion of rare force, persistence, tact, and prescience. In Henry Acland, lately settled in Oxford as a medical practitioner and Lee's Reader in Anatomy, they possessed, say the authors of this little volume with equal truth and justice, a protagonist who had the patience and perseverance, the enthusiasm and unflagging energy, needed for both waiting and working....The foundation of the Museum, and to a great extent the establishment of an Honour School in Science, were in the first place due to his efforts." 66 A few men still survive who were contem: porary with, and took part in, the ten years' struggle which preceded the renaissance. On one side was an acknowledged need: professors demanding space for apparatus, specimens, lectures; stores of material overflowing their narrow bounds, and locked away in drawers or boxes; the old Ashmolean a mockery; Buckland's treasures houseless, as was the unrivalled entomoOn the other side all logical Hope Collection. proposals for a new museum were vehemently opposed-by conservatism hating all things new; by economists predicting limitless outlay; by Tutors jealous of Professors; by classicists denouncing science as intrusive; by the orthodox condemning it as subtly ministrant to false doctrine, heresy, and schism. Acland "worked and waited," gathered round him students, published letters and pamphlets modestly representing Science as the handmaid, not the rival, of Theology; by this means converted Pusey, whose nigra pecudes throughout the country, obediently following their leader, turned the scale of Convocation votes. In 1856 30,0001. were granted for the immediate erection of a Museum; the first stone was laid by the Chancellor, Lord Derby; and by 1860 the partially completed building was handselled by the famous British Association meeting, at which Wilberforce and Huxley disputed over Origin of Species.' The The beautiful details of the new edifice, superintended and developed by Woodward's genius, brought Art as well as Science into Oxford. Woolner and Pollen, Morris and Burne-Jones (the two latter still undergraduates), served under and helped him; Ruskin came to bless, suggest, contribute. Busts of the great men of science, from Bacon onwards, were presented by munificent donors; the columns of the arcades represented a geological series; their capitals were carved in botanical sequence by the Irish brothers O'Shea; the iron supports of the central glass roof were wrought into fruit and foliage by Skidmore. All these interesting details, already lapsing into oblivion, are rescued and preserved in Dr. and Mrs. Vernon's careful compilation, which enumerates also the famous teachers whom the New Learning brought successively to enrich the professorial staff: Phillips, Brodie, Rolleston, Clifton, Moseley, Burdon-Sanderson, Turner, Prestwich, Tylor. One deserving name we are sorry that they should have omitted-that of Charles Robertson, Aldrichian Demonstrator, and Tutor for the Anatomical School. Many men notable to-day look back with gratitude to his conscientious teaching; many, too, amongst the most beautiful biological preparations on the Museum shelves are the work of his dexterous fingers. Living into the opening of a new century, Acland saw, in space, cost, extension, usefulness, his conception trebled; saw ideas embodied which he could not have imagined, yet which were evolved from his immature origination, and due to his self-sacrificing toil. So it has always been. Other men labour, that we may enter into their labours; we in our turn sow and rear, in the belief that, to an extent beyond our knowledge, yet not beyond our hopes, we are forwarding the cause of humanity. Longer Poems, with Introduction and Notes by The English Parnassus : an Anthology of two Scotch professors, Mr. W. M. Dixon and Mr. H. J. C. Grierson, is another of the excellent The volume collections of the Clarendon Press. begins with the Prologue to The Canterbury Tales,' and ends with FitzGerald's Omar The Preface indicates that in the Khayyám. case of this poem, and Tennyson, Browning, excluded the use of some later emendations." and Arnold, "considerations of copyright have The last phrase is inadequate in view of the changes Tennyson made in Mr. Dixon, who has produced a 'Primer of Tennyson, knows perfectly well that the whole of Canto XXXIX. as printed in the final form of This fact should have been frankly stated. We In Memoriam is missing in the text used here. doubt if it is fair at all to reproduce earlier versions of pieces worked over with the utmost care by an artist like Tennyson. At any rate, both in his case and that of FitzGerald the edition used, with the year of its production, should have been indicated. In Memoriam.' Notices to Correspondents. ON all communications must be written the name and address of the sender, not necessarily for publication, but as a guarantee of good faith. WE cannot undertake to answer queries privately. nor can we advise correspondents as to the value of old books and other objects or as to the means of disposing of them. EDITORIAL Communications should be addressed to "The Editor of Notes and Queries'"-Advertisements and Business Letters to "The Pubishers"-at the Office, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C. CECIL CLARKE ("Raleigh or Ralegh "?).-See the numerous contributions at 7 S. i. 252, 396, 455; X. 102, 345, 491; xi. 77, 195; 9 S. vii. 7, 158, 191, 455. V. S. A. (Trichinopoly).-We regret we cannot exchange. THE ATHENÆUM JOURNAL OF ENGLISH AND FOREIGN LITERATURE, SCIENCE, THIS WEEK'S ATHENÆUM contains Articles on JOHNSON'S MRS. THRALE. MEMORIALS OF OLD SUSSEX. PEAKS AND GLACIERS OF NUN KUN. RUBAIYAT OF OMAR KHAYYAM. THE MEDIEVAL CHURCH AND THE PAPACY. 6 NEW NOVELS:-IN THE SHADE. THE NEST OF THE SPARROWHAWK. LOVE SCIENCE:-RESEARCH NOTES; SOCIETIES; GOSSIP. FINE ARTS:-FRENCH MASTERS OF THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY, AND OTHER EXHIBITIONS; ROODSCREENS AND ROODLOFTS; A NEW WORK BY GIACOMO AND GIOVANNI ANGELO MAINO. LAST WEEK'S ATHENÆUM contains Articles on SHELLEY, THE MAN AND THE POET. HOGARTH'S LONDON. THE OXFORD DICTIONARY. THE MEDICI. CLEOPATRA. NEW NOVELS :-The Education of Uncle Paul; Ordinary People; Candles in the Wind; Granite; The Deeper Stain; A Crucial Experiment; Chetwynd's Career. LOCAL HISTORY AND PUBLIC RECORDS. OUR LIBRARY TABLE:-Yet Again; A Century of Empire; An English Honeymoon; Jack Carstairs; Lord Cockburn's Memorials of his Time. PROF. CHARLES GROSS : REGISTER OF THE PRIVY COUNCIL OF SCOTLAND; CAMBRIDGE NOTES; SALES. SCIENCE:-Sir William Huggins's Scientific Papers; Anthropological Notes: Resignation of Dr. E. B. Tylor; Societies; Meetings Next Week; Gossip. FINE ARTS:-Works by Students of the Royal Academy; Other Exhibitions; National Loan Exhibition; Mr. Wakley's Coins; The Earl of Sheffield's Pictures; Gossip, MUSIC:-Fallen Fairies; Symphony Concert; Mackenzie's 'Colomba '; Gossip; Performances Next Week. DRAMA :-The Blue Bird; Globe Theatre Apparel; Gossip. NEXT WEEK'S ATHENÆUM will contain an Article on THE PUBLISHING SEASON AND THE BOOK TRADE. WORK AND PLAY OF A GOVERNMENT INSPECTOR. The ATHENEUM, every SATURDAY, price THREEPENCE, of Athenæum Office, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C. And of all Newsagents. NOW READY. AN ALMANACK FOR THE YEAR OF OUR LORD 1910. BY JOSEPH WHITAKER, F.S.A. CONTAINING AN ACCOUNT OF THE ASTRONOMICAL AND OTHER PHENOMENA. A VAST AMOUNT OF INFORMATION RESPECTING THE GOVERNMENT, FINANCES, POPULATION, COMMERCE, AND GENERAL STATISTICS OF THE BRITISH EMPIRE THROUGHOUT THE WORLD, WITH SOME NOTICE OF OTHER COUNTRIES, &c., &c. LONDON: 12, WARWICK LANE, PATERNOSTER ROW. NOW READY. Whitaker's Peerage, Baronetage, Knightage, and Companionage FOR THE YEAR THE CONTAINING 1910. AN EXTENDED LIST OF THE ROYAL FAMILY, PRIVY COUNCILLORS, AND HOME AND COLONIAL BISHOPS, LONDON: 12, WARWICK LANE, PATERNOSTER ROW, E.C. Published Weekly by JOHN C. FRANCIS and J. EDWARD FRANCIS, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C.: and Printed by J. EDWARD FRANCIS, Athenæum Press, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C.-Saturday, December 25, 1909. INDEX. TENTH SERIES.-VOL. XII. [For classified articles, see ANONYMOUS WORKS, BIBLIOGRAPHY, Books RECENTLY PUBLISHED, Α A. (F. A.) on authors of quotations wanted, 288 payment, 205 Carlyle and Freemasonry: Richard Carlile, 58 Fastolf (Sir John), original letters, 257 Hengler's Circus, 116, 218 Keith's Mayfair marriages, 127 Kendal House, Isleworth, 88 Le Sour's statue of Charles I., 225 Leaden figures, 28 Pigott's Jockey Club,' 174, 412 Rosamond (Fair), 298 St. Dunstan's-in-the-West: its clocks, 49 St. Margaret's, Westminster, east window, Strawberry Hill Catalogue, 216, 491 Temple Bar, 166 Westminster Abbey: western towers, 64 'Abridgement of Calvin's Institution,' 12 Abyssinia W. H. Coffin in, 108, 230; Spanish priests in, 189 oath, 56 Parodies of Kipling, 238 Ackermann (R.) on Thackeray queries, 27 Acorn, 18-gun brig, and slaver Gabriel, 28 Actor v. preacher, 246 Fylde Actors, travelling, courts for, c 1477, 267 Addy (S. O.) on combined monastic and parochial Scottish churches, their ownership, 168 ་ Alleyn (Giles and Christopher), of Holywell, 341 American Hygienic Press Association on vacuum American Indians, monuments to, 87, 230, 358 Andrasta, alluded to by W. Baxter, 1733, 489 Anonymous Works:- American in Paris, 410 Gin a bogie meet a bogie, 509 How a Man may choose a Good Wife, 1602, 67 Short Whist, 264, 318, 357 Vortigern and Rowena, 508 Anscombe (A.) on Cyranus Lucii Regis Pincerna, 269 London: origin of the name, 114 Antiquary's Books, suggestions, 383 Apperson (G. L.) on "All the world and his wife," 13 De Quincey quotations, 139 Hopscotch, 329 Apples, their old names, 137, 254, 398 Archibald (R. C.) on William Gush, painter, 267 Alexandra Institute for the Blind, its history, 68 Arden family, 386 All right, origin of the phrase, 228, 314, 433 Aristotle: Tommy Short on, 70, 392; and the Arkle (A. H.) on "Forget not to give," 269 Armour, parish, 16th century, 422 Army, British, c. 1763, 449, 517 Army List, of Battle of the Boyne, 308 Arnold (Matthew) and the yew, 287, 336, 414 355 Arthur (Prince), 1502, and window in St. Mar- Ayno (Guy and Agnes), and Heynow family, 61 Ayscough (S.) and Taxatio Ecclesiastica Nicho- Axon (W. E. A.) on British Controversialist,' 173 Johnson (Dr.) and Strahan's Virgil,' 85 Newspapers in 1680, 243, 358 Paltock (R.), author of Peter Wilkins,' 286 Southey (Robert), 46 Vegetarian, its derivation, 511 Notes and Queries, Jan. 29, 1910. Abridgement of Calvin's Institution,' 12 Cab cabriolet in Dickens, 514 Christmas Bibliography, 506 Crusoe (Robinson), literary descendants, 79 Dickens Shakespeare: woodbine, 411 Elizabeth (Queen) and 17 November, 404 Gow (Neil and Natt), 172 Gray's Elegy' and ploughing customs, 391 High Stewards temp. Elizabeth, 513 Louis XIV. tablecloth, 498 Paine (Thomas), his remains, 118 Pig grass fioning grass, 92 |