CASES DECIDED

IN THE

SUPREME COURT

OF

MICHIGAN

FROM

NOVEMBER 8, 1912, TO MARCH 20, 1913

Copyright, 1913, by Frederick C. Martindale, Secretary of State,

for the State of Michigan.

SUPREME COURT.

CHIEF JUSTICE.

TERM EXPIRES
Dec. 31, 1913

JOSEPH B. MOORE, LAPEER,
JOSEPH H. STEERE,' SAULT ST. MARIE,

Dec. 31, 1913

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOSEPH B. MOORE,' LAPEER,
JOSEPH H. STEERE, SAULT STE. MARIE, .
AARON V. MCALVAY, MANISTEE,
FLAVIUS L. BROOKE, DETROIT,
FRANZ C. KUHN, MT. CLEMENS,
JOHN W. STONE, MARQUETTE,
RUSSELL C. OSTRANDER, LANSING,
JOHN E. BIRD, ADRIAN,

Dec. 31, 1913
Dec. 31, 1913
Deo. 31, 1915
Dec. 31, 1915

Dec. 31, 1917

Dec. 31, 1917
Dec. 31, 1919
Dec. 31, 1919

CLERK—CHARLES C. HOPKINS, LANSING.

CRIER-ANDREW B. CHAPIN, LANSING.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

ROGER I. WYKES, GRAND RAPIDS.
GRANT FELLOWS, HUDSON.

To December 31, 1912. ? From January 1, 1913.

CIRCUIT JUDGES.

1. 2.

HILLSDALE.
ST. JOSEPH.

8.

DETROIT.

.

4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.

GUY M. CHESTER,
GEORGE W. BRIDGMAN,
'ALFRED J. MURPHY,
GEORGE S. HOSMER,
HENRY A. MANDELL,
P. J. M. HALLY,
GEORGE P. CODD,
(PHILIP T. VAN ZILE,
JAMES A. PARKINSON,
CLEMENT SMITH,
GEORGE W. SMITH,
CHARLES H. WISNER,
FRANK D. M. DAVIS,
FRANK E. KNAPPEN,
SWILLIAM G. GAGE,
WILLIAM R. KENDRICK,
ROBERTS P. HUDSON,
LOUIS H. FEAD,
PATRICK H. O'BRIEN,
FREDERICK W. MAYNE,
JAMES E. SULLIVAN,
FREDERICK W. KNOWLEN,
JAMES G. TUCKER,

JAOKSON.
HASTINGS.
PONTIAO.
FLINT.
IONIA.
KALAMAZOO.

10.

SAGINAW.

11.

12. 13. 14. 15. 16.

SAULT STE. MARIE.
NEWBERRY.
HOUGHTON.
CHARLEVOIX.
MUSKEGON.
CONSTANTINE.
Mr. CLEMENS.

JOHN S. MODONALD

GRAND RAPIDS.

17. WILLIS B. PERKINS,

WILLIAM B. BROWN, 18. CHESTER L. COLLINS, 19. CHARLES A. WITHEY, 20. ORIEN S. CROSS, 21. PETER F. DODDS, 22. EDWARD D. KINNE, . 23. MAIN J. CONNINE, 24. WATSON BEACH, 25. RICHARD C. FLANNIGAN, 26. FRANK EMERICK, 27. JOSEPH BARTON, 28. FRED S. LAMB,

1 Elected November 5, 1912, to fill vacancy.

BAY CITY.
REED CITY.
ALLEGAN.
Mr. PLEASANT.
ANN ARBOR.
OSCODA.
LEXINGTON.
NORWAY
ALPENA.
BIG RAPIDE.
CADILLAO.

1

SUPERIOR COURT OF GRAND RAPIDS, WILLIAM J. STUART.