| 1914 - 918 sidor
...judicial review of such judgment is limited. "The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of power is not to be confused with the scope of legislative considerations in dealing with the matter of polic\. Whether the enactment is wise or unwise, whether it is based on sound economic theory, whether... | |
| United States. Supreme Court - 1918 - 1592 sidor
...524, 42 L. ed. 260, 262, 17 Sup. Ct. Rep. 864. Whether a law is wise or unwise, whether based upon u ` u @ u are matters for the judgment of the state legislative body. And the earnest conflict of serious opinion... | |
| United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on the Judiciary - 1974 - 1838 sidor
...is ended. In the v of Justice Hughes in Chicago, Burlington and Quine Railroad Co. v. McGuire, 219 US 549, 569 (1911): "The scope of judicial inquiry...whether, in short, the legislative discretion within it prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular manner, are matters for the judg ment of the... | |
| United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on the Judiciary - 1990 - 766 sidor
...decline to exercise the powers ascribed to the other two branches . Our Illinois Supreme Court observed "[w]hether the enactment is wise or unwise, whether...whether it is the best means to achieve the desired results, and whether the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in... | |
| 1998 - 394 sidor
...Court's judgment. "The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of power," Hughes declared, "is not to be confused with the scope of legislative considerations in dealing with a matter of policy."." The McGuire decision had a limited scope, but it saved the prohibitions on "contracting... | |
| William G. Ross - 2007 - 316 sidor
...prohibitions imposed in the interests of the community. The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of power is not to be confused with the scope of legislative...considerations in dealing with the matter of policy.™ Hughes also compiled a liberal record on social issues. Ahead of his time on gender issues, Hughes,... | |
| 1911 - 1196 sidor
...discretion is not subject to judicial review. The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of power is not to be confused with the scope of legislative...best means to achieve the desired result, whether, m short, the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular... | |
| |